Some people don't like this movie, and I'm not sure why. The happy ending? The Ewoks? The death of the Bad Guy?
I loved this movie. The good guys won, things were right with the universe. So what if there were Ewok toys?
Luke has matured into a true Jedi, inexperienced maybe, but he's learned how to handle his fears, but maybe not his emotions. I do love his manly act in Jabba's palace. That calm serenity, the certainty that he and his friends will survive, is quite compelling.
Han is a little down at first, certain they're going to die, but he gets back to his old roughish self. Nice trick in impressing Leia by volunteering to lead the Endor strike team. But it's also a sign of his maturity, perhaps brought on by his brush with death. All of them.
Leia is amazing here. From sneaking into Jabba's palace, (I thought that was Lando in the helmet the first time), to accepting Luke's revelations with such serenity. And she's a great shot with a blaster pistol. I definitely want her on my side of the war!
Lando turns out to be a good guy after all, as we suspected in TESB. He just had to be shamed into doing the right thing. I think seeing his buddy Han in the carbonite block woke him up! He finally becomes "responsible".
Yoda dies. Sniff. But hey, when 900 years old you reach, you'll already be dead! It was his time. He lived long enough to see the last of the Jedi trained. I suppose he could have asked Luke to take him to a Medical Center, but I think he was ready to go. "That is the way of things, the way of the Force!"
Obi-Wan appears again, and he's become strong enough in the netherworld of the Force that he can hold a conversation with Luke! No cryptic messages this time. I hope I'm as wise and talkative when I've been dead for a few years.
He's convinced that Luke needs to kill Vader, and I tend to agree. But Luke is more forgiving, and willing to try to save him. He's a little hung up on the father thing, you see. I can't say I'd be as loyal had my father tried to kill me before I was born, but that's just me.
Ewoks. Some people love them, some hate them, and some don't care. I don't care. Lucas said he had always wanted to do a great battle of a primitive culture versus the high tech one. Man vs. the machine. My hubby loves the two logs hitting the walker scene.
The lightsaber duel. Yeah, it was awesome. Again, Luke is a little pacifistic for my taste, but he's so strong emotionally that it works for me. (He's a better Jedi than I am)
I'm not so certain that one last act redeems Anakin, but it was a good start. Had he lived, he would have MUCH to answer for and it's probably better that he dies.
The Emperor gets his just desserts! On a side note, in "Robot Chicken" that's the day he says, "Could this day get any worse?"
This movie is full of rich details that take several watchings to notice. The Rancor keeper's tears, Yoda's blanket, the ships out the window of the Death Star, snakes on Dagobah, the Ewoks playing the drums on the helmets, etc.
I have split feelings on the appearance of the young Anakin at the end of the Special Edition. Where I think the original actor was too old, Hayden Christensen is too young. He might have looked better had they digitally aged him to 45 or so, more realistic. I know the theory that really dies when he falls to the dark side, but he turned back at the end, so he should look like that.
Up next? I have no idea!
8 comments:
shoppingMaul61
date Posted: Feb 24, 2009 2:42 PM
I prefer Shaw because I was a fan in '83 and psychologically find it jarring to see another dude standing there. It was such a big deal to see Vader unmasked back then and it only seems fitting (to older fans anyway) that the prequels be the story of that man when he was younger. I never had a problem with Jake or Hayden being younger depictions of Shaw. I love the prequels but feel they should honor the OT, not the other way around. In my opinion those kinds of changes actually detract from the continuity rather than enhance it. I understand it's probably different for younger fans though.
leia19886
Someone get this big walking carpet out of my way ...
date Posted: Feb 24, 2009 6:53 PM
Excellent job !!
I like the idea of seeing Anakin with Obi-Wan and Yoda, but I'm with you if you going to put Hayden, age him a little. My sister's theroy is that if you gunna put Hayden, they should have but Qui-Gon and Mace also.
The Viridian Saber (Qui-Gon Reborn)
Virtual Unrealities (A victim of Order 66.)
date Posted: Feb 24, 2009 11:08 PM
Some people don't like this movie, and I'm not sure why.
Me neither, really. I tried to watch the movie once -- acting not as a fan who loves all of the films but a harsh critic -- but I couldn't find anything wrong with it. It had everything that a Star Wars movie is supposed to have! Action, romance, drama, tragedy, humor, Force philosophizing and lightsaber battles...what's not to like?
The Ewoks...well, if you kind of look around them, they're not so bad.
Luke has matured into a true Jedi, inexperienced maybe, but he's learned how to handle his fears, but maybe not his emotions.
To paraphrase Luke Skywalker and the Shadows of Mindor, unlike the Jedi of old, Luke Skywalker was fundamentally different. He had no fear of the dark.
Now, that's a pure generalization. Some Jedi, like Qui-Gon Jinn, took a more foward approach to the Force and its dark side. Instead of pushing it away and trying to find ways around it, like Mace Windu and, sometimes Yoda, did, these more liberally minded Jedi sought to understand the nature of the dark side, and to accept it. That's one of the fundamental things that allowed Luke to redeem his father.
but I think he was ready to go. "That is the way of things, the way of the Force!"
Yeah, but it breaks my heart every time.
(He's a better Jedi than I am)
You can say that again./So certain are you?
(I couldn't decide which one to say, so I'll say 'em both.) :p
I know the theory that he really dies when he falls to the dark side, but he turned back at the end, so he should look like that.
Well, when he returned to the light, he essentially returned to the person he once was, minus the arrogance. So it makes sense for him to look the same, yet more serene and drenched in symbolism with the lighter color tunic.
Up next? I have no idea!
TCW? How about some EU stuff? We want more!
they should have but Qui-Gon and Mace also.
Liam Neeson was going to be edited in, but he was in a motorcycle accident when he was on the way to a grocery store to buy muffins and bones for the dogs. :8} :^O
Mace Windu had no knowledge of the power Qui-Gon learned from the Shaman of the Whills.
shoppingMaul61
date Posted: Feb 25, 2009 4:44 AM
Again, let me offer an 'older fan' perspective...
I was 8yrs old when ANH came out. Empire came out when I was 11 and by this stage I was getting into darker themes and stories as teenagers do. So by the time Jedi came out (and I was 14) a lot of fans like myself were hoping the grittier vibe of Empire would continue (don't forget at this time Lucas had claimed it was a 9 episode saga). Some of us felt Luke might succumb to the Dark side and take his father's mantle. Some speculated that the 'other hope' might be Luke's real dad, and that Vader was Skywalker's clone. There was a lot to think about and a lot of potential darkness to be had!
- so when it all turned out so (comparitively) rosey - Vader was Luke's dad, Luke saved him, the teddy bears saved the Galaxy etc etc it seemed a little anticlimactic for pent up punks like me! I really loved it - don't get me wrong - but it was later in life, when viewing the saga in better context and with a little less testosterone coursing through my veins, that I really understood ROTJ and how it figures in the greater scheme.
Sorry about the life story! Just thought I'd share...
Again, let me offer an 'older fan' perspective.
I'm way older than you! :) Well, in my generation, stories had Happy Endings, and heroes were heroes.
Although Vader was undeniably popular, even back in 1977.
JediMelindaWolf
Try not. Do. Or do not. There is no try.
date Posted: Mar 03, 2009 7:54 AM
I loved this movie.
Me, too!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! :D
Luke, :x bless his heart, is a stronger Jedi, and looks good in black! Just goes to show that the good guys can sport that color as well. ;)
Loved the ewoks. It never bothered me that they were these cute, furry creatures. Cute? Maybe. Furry? Yes. But boy oh boy, did they know how to fight!!!
MTFBWY :)
TrekMaster13
StarWars fans at wars?
date Posted: Mar 06, 2009 10:17 PM
I think the best scene in all of SW is the end of ROTJ when the entire galaxy is partying. OMG THAT WOULD BE SOOOOO SWEET!!!! lmao
I know the theory that really dies when he falls to the dark side, but he turned back at the end, so he should look like that.
It would suck for someone to have their head cut off and then comeback from the afterlife with no head lol.
It would suck for someone to have their head cut off and then comeback from the afterlife with no head lol.
Good point!
Post a Comment